top of page

to the CharityBox Blog!


This post may contain advertisements to support our site and CharityBox Community. We only promote products & services that have been pre-approved by our CharityBox Experts

The Power of Donor Tiering: Nurturing Major Donors for Sustainable Impact

Check out our Fundraising Box!

Nonprofit organizations rely heavily on the generosity of their donors to fund their missions and initiatives. While every contribution is valuable, it's essential for nonprofit professionals to recognize the significance of donor tiering and how it can drive long-term sustainability and growth. By prioritizing and treating big donors as valuable partners, nonprofits can foster stronger relationships, ensure donor retention, and increase contributions. In this article, CharityBox will explore the importance of donor tiering and strategies for effectively engaging both big and small donors while allocating time and resources appropriately.

Understanding Donor Tiering

Donor tiering involves categorizing donors based on the level of their contributions and engagement with the organization. While donor tiers will be different for each organization, it is important that you clearly define your tiers in a way that makes sense to your organization’s capacity. A handful of Major Donors will demand more staff time than 5,000 Donor Prospects. This segmentation allows nonprofits to differentiate their approach to cultivating relationships, ensuring that they invest their time and resources where it matters most.

a. Major Donors: Major donors are those whose contributions significantly impact the organization's financial stability. They may contribute large one-time gifts or make substantial recurring donations. These donors demand personalized ongoing attention and special recognition for their support.

b. Mid-level Donors: Mid-level donors fall between major donors and small donors in terms of giving capacity. Although their contributions may not be as substantial, they still play a critical role in sustaining the organization.

c. Small Donors: Small donors, while contributing modest amounts, collectively form a substantial source of funding for nonprofits. Their consistent support demonstrates loyalty and a shared commitment to the cause.

D. Donor Prospects: Anyone in a nonprofit’s audience should be treated as a donor prospect, this includes your volunteers, subscribers, followers, and more. Prospects are future small-donors, and should begin receiving your end of year campaign and soft asks on social media, the website, newsletter, and more.

The Importance of Treating Major Donors as VIPs

a. Personalized Engagement: Major donors expect a higher level of personalized engagement. Reach out to them directly a handful of times throughout the year to express gratitude,and keep them updated on the impact of their contributions. Tailored communications foster a sense of belonging and connection to the organization's mission. Requests for major gifts are always best done in-person.

b. Exclusive Benefits: Offer special benefits to major donors, such as invitations to exclusive events, behind-the-scenes access, or opportunities to meet with key stakeholders. These perks demonstrate appreciation for their commitment and make them feel valued. Furthermore, they can be a great opportunity to showcase your mission in action and prove value.

c. Recognize Their Impact: Publicly acknowledge the significant contributions of major donors through newsletters, annual reports, or recognition plaques. Highlighting their impact encourages continued support and inspires others to follow suit. Importantly, find the way that the major donor wants to be recognized, it is never one-size fits all.

Strategies for Engaging Small Donors Effectively

a. Efficient Communication: Utilize email newsletters and social media to keep small donors informed about the organization's activities and accomplishments. Engaging content with consistent soft asks helps maintain their interest and encourages ongoing support.

b. Automated Donor Stewardship: Implement automated systems for thanking small donors and sending regular updates on the organization's progress. This approach allows nonprofits to allocate more time to major donor stewardship while ensuring small donors still feel appreciated.

c. Monthly Giving Programs: Encourage donors to join monthly giving programs. Monthly contributions, even if modest, provide nonprofits with predictable revenue and foster a sense of ongoing partnership with donors.

Balancing Time and Resources

a. Develop a Stewardship Plan: Create a detailed stewardship plan that outlines the type of engagement for different donor tiers. Clearly define the activities and communication frequency for each group to avoid overlooking any segment. Place calendar holds for tasks throughout the year to make sure they get done.

b. Cultivate Relationships with Mid-level Donors: Mid-level donors have the potential to become major donors. Cultivate these relationships by inviting them to participate in select events and involving them in smaller-scale leadership opportunities.

c. Volunteer Engagement: Engage small donors in volunteer activities to maintain a connection beyond their financial contributions. Volunteering can foster a sense of fulfillment and commitment to the organization's mission.

D. Delegate: Clearly define fundraising roles to the staff and board and update job descriptions accordingly. Everyone on the team should understand the necessity of fundraising and participate, even if only sharing a sponsorship package or directing those interested to the donation page.


Donor tiering is an indispensable strategy for nonprofit professionals seeking to optimize their fundraising efforts. By treating big donors as valued partners and strategically engaging small donors, nonprofits can build strong and lasting relationships with all supporters. Properly allocating time and resources based on donor tiers not only boosts donor retention but also creates a sustainable foundation for long-term impact and success in pursuing the organization's mission.

Check out our Fundraising Box!


Check out the CharityBox Store for affordable templates and tools!

Ready to turn your knowledge into action?

bottom of page